Tim (littlebluedog) wrote,
Tim
littlebluedog

  • Mood:

teh eljay

Maybe it's the mood I'm in or something, but I'm having a really hard time understanding the widespread uproar regarding SixApart's decision to suspend or delete a few journals. Irritation I can understand, disagreement I can understand, but so much of the seems to be vitriolic indignation in response to a business decision relative to a complaint from an outside source, one that actually has some degree of legitimacy: "Hey, some of the journals on your site promote pedophilia."

SA: "OMG I think you're right." *baleet*

LJ USERS EVERYWHERE: "OMG FUCKIN NAZIS!"

SA made an error by getting a little overinclusive with the journals it deleted. Considering this was done in many cases solely on interests listed, I can't see that this was unforgiveable. Although it's not directly pertinent to the complaint, about 40 coms and ten times as many users list "killing people" as an interest, so I'd SA is still being fairly liberal in allowing folks to write about any damn thing they feel like. 500 journals were deleted, out of 13 million ... that's less than 4 thousandths of one percent. I just can't follow the logic of the outcry, especially in light of what I see as apologetic, sincere, and prompt attempts to try to rectify the error. Would it be better if the deletion was underinclusive, or if SA had disregarded the complaint?

SA is a business. Like any other business, the consumer has a choice -not- to avail him/her/itself of the services provided, on the terms set. I hate the well-worn "if you don't like it here, then leave" mantra, and that's not my point with this. My point is to have some perspective on how a business operates, and realize that you're really not entitled to that much.
Subscribe

  • Vegas Trip rundown

    Nic and I just had a long weekend in Vegas. Her folks treated us, in honor of Nic's Spring Break and completion of the first part of her nursing…

  • weekend, I Am Number Four

    Very silly. I'm not sure what I expected; I persuaded my friend Dave to see it with me today based on the trailer alone, which I saw some weeks…

  • bippity bop

    Incremental progress is still progress. Of course, when you have to describe it that way, it's nothing to get excited about. Talking, of course,…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 34 comments

  • Vegas Trip rundown

    Nic and I just had a long weekend in Vegas. Her folks treated us, in honor of Nic's Spring Break and completion of the first part of her nursing…

  • weekend, I Am Number Four

    Very silly. I'm not sure what I expected; I persuaded my friend Dave to see it with me today based on the trailer alone, which I saw some weeks…

  • bippity bop

    Incremental progress is still progress. Of course, when you have to describe it that way, it's nothing to get excited about. Talking, of course,…